37 Herkimer sales and 63 Oneida arm's-length deeds last week. Who closed them, the biggest sales, and 5 Herkimer listings to watch.
Who's Closing — powered by TitleTrackr Issue #1 · Weekly
This week in Herkimer & Oneida
Week of Oct 5–13, 2026 · Herkimer Oct 5–12 (verified thru 10/12) · Oneida Oct 7–13 (verified thru 10/13)
 
Here's who handled the deeds recorded in both counties last week. Attorneys and title companies are ranked separately and by sales only, so trust transfers and family deeds don't pad the numbers.
Herkimer County
Recorded Oct 5–12 · verified thru 10/12/2026
59
Deeds recorded
all types
37
Sales
consideration > $1K
$140K
Median sale
37 sales
Oneida County
Recorded Oct 7–13 · verified thru 10/13/2026
97
Deeds recorded
90 analyzed
63
Arm's-length
of 90, est.
20
To trusts
estate planning
Active listings on Zillow: Herkimer 360 (median list $224,950), Oneida 848 (median list $264,950), based on 100 listings pulled per county.
Herkimer County
Deeds recorded Oct 5–12, 2026 · IQS verified thru 10/12/2026 · 37 sales, 8 to trusts, 14 family/heir/nominal
Attorneys closing sales
Law firms on the return-to line of Herkimer deeds
Manne & Humpf
Herkimer
 3 sales
Joslin Legal Services
Newport
 2 sales
1 sale each (6): Cirillo Law Firm, Compson & Pimpinella, Edward Kaminski, Esq., Marino Law Group, Parshall & West, Rose & Brinski
No sales, estate-planning or family deeds only: Hilton Estate & Elder Law (2 to trust); Rheinhardt & Bray (2 family/heir); Barclay Damon (1 to trust); Consentino Snyder & Quinn (1 family/heir); Costello Cooney & Fearon (1 family/heir); DiGiorgio Law Firm (1 to trust); George F. Aney, Esq. (1 family/heir); Ward Arcuri Foley & Dwyer (1 to trust)
Title & abstract companies
Abstract and title companies on the return-to line
Leatherstocking Abstract & Title
Utica
 5 sales
Mohawk Valley Abstract
Clinton · +1 non-sale
 2 sales
Allied American Abstract
Utica
 1 sale
Biggest sales
Herkimer only. The Oneida index doesn't show sale prices.
PricePropertyReturned to
$2,550,000 67 Little Moose Lake
Webb (T) · trust-to-trust		 Leatherstocking Abstract & Title
Title / abstract
$2,500,000 2517 South Shore Road
Webb (T)		 E-recorded
firm not shown in index
$650,000 195 Wolf Creek Road
Ohio (T)		 E-recorded
firm not shown in index
$440,000 809 Peckville Road
Manheim (T)		 E-recorded
firm not shown in index
$320,000 3120 School St
Newport (V)		 Joslin Legal Services
Attorney
$299,999 12 Brookside Drive
Mohawk (V)		 Leatherstocking Abstract & Title
Title / abstract
New listings to watch · Herkimer only
Live Herkimer listings where the seller's own purchase deed names an attorney
1392 Big Moose Rd, Eagle Bay
$895,000 · Dawn Timm · Timm Associates Sotheby's
Likely seller attorney: Donald R Gerace Atty, Utica (seller's 2021 deed)
 High
114 E German St, Herkimer
$182,000 · C. Vitiello · Coldwell Banker Faith Properties
Likely seller attorney: Getnick Law Firm, Utica (seller's 2021 deed)
 High
685 Hardscrabble Rd, Little Falls
$164,900 · Trevor Worden · Coldwell Banker Faith Properties
Likely seller attorney: Malone and Malone, Little Falls (seller's 2021 deed)
 High
179 Church St, Little Falls
$149,900 · William Macri · Joe Macri Realty
Likely seller attorney: Audrey Baron Dunning Esq, Ilion (seller's 2020 deed)
 High
115 Riverside Dr E, Old Forge
$895,000 · Tory M Dunn · Herron Realty
Likely seller attorney: SJ Capecelatro, Utica (seller's 2017 deed)
 Medium
Run a title search in TitleTrackr →
Confidence: High = attorney on a seller deed from 2020 or later; Medium = older deed. This is a rough estimate. The seller may choose a different attorney.
Oneida County
Deeds recorded Oct 7–13, 2026 · IQS verified thru 10/13/2026 · first 90 of 97 deeds analyzed
Attorneys closing arm's-length deeds
Law firms on the return-to line. Oneida shows no price, so "arm's-length" means unrelated buyer and seller, not a trust.
Goldbas & LaReaux
Utica
 5 arm's-length deeds
Festine Nelson (Kathryn Festine)
Utica
 3 arm's-length deeds
1 arm's-length deed each (15): Calli Calli & Cully, Dague Law Office, David M. Giglio & Associates, Felt Evans, Gustave J. DeTraglia Jr., Kalil & Kalil, Michelle Gu, Esq., Murad & Murad, Oshins Law Office, Paul M. Longeretta, Esq., Saunders Kahler, Schmitt & Lascurettes, Shane & Firkle, Ward Arcuri Foley & Dwyer, William M. Borrill, Esq.
No sales, estate-planning or family deeds only: Davies Law Firm (4 to trust); Kenny Elder Law (4 to trust); Hilton Estate & Elder Law (3 to trust); Cohen & Cohen (2 family/heir); Compson & Pimpinella (1 family/heir); Rheinhardt & Bray (1 to trust); Warren Law Office (1 to trust)
Title & abstract companies
Abstract and title companies on the return-to line
Advantage Abstract
Utica
 1 arm's-length deed
Only one Oneida deed went back to a title company. 27 of the 90 were e-recorded, which usually hides who filed them.
Busiest towns · Oneida
Deeds recorded by town, with the share that look like arm's-length sales
Utica
  15 (13 arm's-length)
Whitestown
 9 (9 arm's-length)
Vernon
 7 (7 arm's-length)
New Hartford
  7 (5 arm's-length)
Rome
  7 (5 arm's-length)
Sangerfield
  6 (1 arm's-length)
   
■ 63 likely arm's-length   ■ 20 to a trust   ■ 7 between family members
Sangerfield had 6 deeds, but 5 went into trusts: 3 through Kenny Elder Law and 2 through Davies Law Firm.
Not attributed to a firm: Herkimer 23 e-recorded and 4 returned to a party to the deed. Oneida 27 e-recorded and 20 returned to a party, an LLC, or an unverified individual. Herkimer sales are deeds with consideration over $1,000. Oneida arm's-length is estimated from the names because its index has no price.
Who's Closing
Who's Closing
POWERED BYTitleTrackr
Data from county public records and listing sites.
You're receiving this because you signed up at whosclosing.com.
Rankings come from public records and can't be bought. Who's Closing is owned by TitleTrackr; a TitleTrackr founder also owns Allied American Abstract.
Who's Closing by TitleTrackr · [company address]